Showing posts with label derechos humanos. Show all posts
Showing posts with label derechos humanos. Show all posts

Monday, September 30, 2013

Guanajuato Preaudience Denounces Violations of Right to Clean Water // Preaudiencia Guanajuatense Denuncia Violaciones del Derecho al Agua Limpia

This past September 20th saw the presentation of the National Preaudience on the Devastation of the National Hydraulic System in Mexico.  The hearing was an incredible experience, with 13 cases presenting over the course of the day.  Roughly 500-600 individuals attended throughout the day. 
Despite the wonderful attendance, many were unable to attend in person.  For those unable to be present, there is a wealth of information available about the hearing, as well as about the case presented by the Coalición en Defensa de la Cuenca de la Independencia (CODECIN).  Some of those materials will be shared here in this space.

////////////////////

El pasado 20 de septiembre, se realizo la Preaudiencia Nacional sobre la Devastación del Sistema Hídrico Nacional.  La Preaudiencia fue una experiencia increíble, con la presentación de 13 casos sobre el transcurso del día.  Alrededor de 500-600 personas asistieron al evento durante el día.
Aunque hubo una asistencia muy buena, muchos no pudieron asistir en persona.  Para las personas quienes no pudieron estar presente, exista una gran cantidad de información sobre la Preaudiencia, tanto sobre el caso presentado por el anfitrión, la Coalición en Defensa de la Cuenca de la Independencia (CODECIN).  Se compartirá algunos de estos materiales aquí en este espacio. 

////////////////////

1) An impressive article chronicling the day of the Preaudience. // Un articulo  impresionante con una crónica del día de la Preaudiencia: 

Castellano:



2) Audio recordings of the case presentations during the hearing. // Grabación por audio de la presentación de los casos durante la Preaudiencia: http://hijosmadretierra.blogspot.mx/2013/09/preaudiencia-devastacion-del-sistema.html

////////////////////

            As more documentation of the hearing is made available, this website will continue to update with those resources. // Mientras que se publica más documentación de la Preaudiencia, este sitio se actualizará con dichos recursos.



 Photo courtesy of CATIS-Mexico. 
Foto cortesia de CATIS-Mexico.


Photo courtesy of the Periódico Ketzalkoatl.  
Foto cortesia del Periódico Ketzalkoatl.



Monday, September 9, 2013

Publicidad Sigue por la Preaudiencia Nacional en Guanajuato

La Asamblea Nacional de Afectados Ambientales (ANAA) difunda publicidad sobre la Preaudiencia Nacional "Devastación del Sistema Hídrico Nacional", el 20 de Septiembre en Guanajuato:


Thursday, May 16, 2013

The Mexico Chapter of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal: Free Trade, Violence, Impunity and Peoples’ Rights


            Legal systems are established to deliver justice to wrongfully injured parties.  Nevertheless, in societies around the world, the law is frequently used to impede, rather than to facilitate, access to justice.  In such situations, the State might use its attributes and powers to benefit private interests that are contrary and prejudicial to public interests.  The Mexico chapter of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal (PPT) characterizes this phenomenon -- of private interests’ co-opting a State and diverting the State’s resources to private, rather than public, needs -- as “desviacion de poder”: that is, “misuse of power.”[1]

            The concept of “misuse of power” is the central concern of the Mexico chapter of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal (PPT).  The Tribunal does not simply affirm legal rights, but also highlights the incompatibility of the free trade economic model with universally recognized rights.[2]  In the Mexico chapter of the Tribunal, the Tribunal’s main theme is “Free Trade, Violence, Impunity, and Peoples’ Rights.”

General Structure of the Mexico Chapter of the Tribunal

            To understand the Tribunal’s work in Mexico, one must understand the Tribunal’s structure.  The Tribunal consists of different audiences and pre-audiences throughout Mexico.  The audiences include (i) a general introductory audience; (ii) seven thematic audiences; and (iii) a final audience. 

The Tribunal held a general introductory audience during May 2012 in Ciudad Juarez in the state of Chihuahua.  At this audience, the Tribunal listened to communities and organizations present evidence on the destructive relationship between free trade policies and the seven thematic audience topics.  The Tribunal issued a finding at the end of the general introductory audience about the results of the hearing and initiated the seven thematic audiences.[3]

The seven thematic audiences will continue until the Tribunal adjourns in 2014.  These separate audiences, which are the Tribunal’s “work groups,” cover the following topics: (i) dirty war; (ii) violence against migrants; (iii) violence against women; (iv) violence against workers; (v) violence against food sovereignty; (vi) environmental devastation; and (vii) violence against the media.

Each thematic audience will involve a hearing devoted to one of these topics, considered in relation to the structural violence produced by a free trade, neoliberal economic model.  For example, the Tribunal’s judges will hold a separate hearing on the violence inflicted on women by this economic model.  The Tribunal’s judges will also hold a separate hearing on the environmental devastation caused by free trade neoliberal policies. 

During the separate thematic audiences, the goal is to reveal the relationship that each theme has to violence generated by free trade neoliberal economic policies.  The Tribunal encourages the presenting of witnesses’ testimony at each audience, but does not require it.  Each thematic audience lasts about a day and a half or two days.  The judges issue a finding that is made public at the end of the audience.  Because the Tribunal is a public opinion court, the findings do not legally bind the State or individuals.  Nevertheless, grassroots movements and organizations may use the findings as part of their overall strategies for engaging in civil resistance.

After the seven hearings for the different thematic audiences, the Tribunal will conclude with a final audience.  In the final audience, the judges will use the information collected and the findings issued in the other hearings to discuss free trade’s adverse impact on the rights of the people, to indicate those responsible for violating the people’s rights, to publicize the violations, and to shed light on the relationships between free trade, violence, and the judicial system.[4]

Structure of the Thematic Audiences and Pre-Audiences

Although the work done in each thematic audience is notable, the bulk of the grassroots component of the Tribunal arguably occurs during the pre-audiences. 

The next article in this series will examine the pre-audiences, their structure, their importance to the Tribunal’s mission, and their role in organizing communities practicing civil resistance.





[1] Silvia Ribeiro, Desviación de Poder, La Jornada, July 28, 2012, at  http://www.jornada.unam.mx/2012/07/28/opinion/028a1eco.

[2] Tribunal Permanente de los Pueblos, Boletín Informativo No. 3, at http://www.tppmexico.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/BOLETIN-3-TPP-CAPITULO-MEXICO.pdf.  

[3] Tribunal Permanente de los Pueblos, Dictamen de la Audiencia General Introductoria, May 27-29, 2012, at http://www.tppmexico.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/TPP-Ciudad-Juarez-definitivo-1.pdf.

[4] Tribunal Permanente de los Pueblos, Boletín Informativo No. 3, at http://www.tppmexico.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/BOLETIN-3-TPP-CAPITULO-MEXICO.pdf.   

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

The Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal: An Experiment in Populist Justice


            Imagine, for a moment, that the State has polluted your water with toxic levels of arsenic, or robbed you of your family land, or disappeared your brother, or assassinated the members of your community. Where would you seek redress?  To what forum would you take a case of that nature?
                                 
            If a society’s legal system still functions properly to some extent, you might find “relief” in that society’s courts.  But, in a society where the legal system no longer functions - where the legal system has broken down completely - one cannot hope for justice in that society’s courts.  Instead, new spaces for such cases are needed - like the proceedings held by international courts.

            International courts generally come in two different kinds.  First, there are the courts whose jurisdiction States have recognized by treaty or statute.  Then, there are “opinion tribunals,” whose jurisdiction States have not recognized.  Currently, two opinion tribunals of substantial weight are being conducted in the world today: (i) the Russell Tribunal, which just completed its final session investigating allegations of human rights abuses in Palestine; and (ii) the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal, which is currently holding hearings on allegations of human rights abuses throughout Mexico.

            This article is the first in a series of articles that will discuss the work of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal in Mexico - its history, structure, goals, role as a community-organizing tool, and legal findings.  This Tribunal provides the opportunity to fuse legal advocacy with grassroots movements, meaning it is a legal experiment with great potential both for organizing communities and justice advocates alike.
             
“Public Opinion” Courts

The Russell Tribunal and the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal are “public opinion courts,” convened by citizens who seek a forum in which to present legal complaints, usually against a government or State-supported actors.  Because they are “public opinion” courts, they do not have legal status or the power to enforce their judgments.  Nevertheless, due to the prominence and respect accorded to members of these Tribunals, their pronouncements (decided based on evidence presented in court) exert social pressure on the State to take action against those found guilty in Tribunal proceedings   

For communities charging the State with human rights violations, these Tribunals serve as an alternative to the State courts.  Presenting a case against the State in a domestic court may prove impossible, dangerous, or pointless.  These opinion tribunals are a grassroots solution to counteract the impediments faced when bringing a case against the State in its own court.

History of the Russell Tribunal and the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal

After the Vietnam War, British philosopher Bertrand Russell and French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre joined other notable public figures to form the Russell Tribunal.  The original purpose of the Russell Tribunal was to provide a forum in which witnesses could testify about war crimes committed during the Vietnam War, particularly war crimes committed by United States’ military forces.

The Russell Tribunal began its work in 1966 and 1967 by holding hearings on the Vietnam War in various cities in Europe.  After the hearings on the Vietnam War, the Russell Tribunal held hearings from 1973 through 1976 on human rights violations in Latin America.  After the Latin American hearings, the Russell Tribunal did not convene for twenty-five years.  Thereafter, the Russell Tribunal held a series of hearings on various subjects: a hearing in 2001 on Human Rights in Psychiatry; a hearing in 2004 on war crimes in Iraq; and, beginning in 2009, hearings on Palestine, lasting from 2009-2013.[1]

During the quarter century that the Russell Tribunal was inactive, Italian Senator Lelio Basso sought to continue the work of opinion tribunals on a permanent basis.[2]  He sought to identify and to publicize cases of systematic violations of fundamental human rights, particularly those in which legislation failed to protect the people facing oppression.[3]  Concerning the legitimacy of public opinion courts, Basso stated: 

“The needs of public conscience can become a recognized source of law [...] and a tribunal that emanates directly from the popular consciousness reflects an idea that will make headway: institutionalized powers and the people, from whom the former claim legitimacy in actual fact tend to diverge and only a truly popular initiative can try to bridge the gap between people and power.”[4]

            In 1979, Basso founded the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal (PPT) in Italy on the basis of principles set forth in the Universal Declaration of the Rights of Peoples.  The Tribunal headquarters remain in Italy.  Currently, the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal comprises more than 130 members of high moral reputation.  Its President is Salvatore Senese, and its Secretary General is Gianni Tognoni.

            To date, the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal has held thirty-six sessions all over the world, including recent sessions in Sri Lanka, the Philippines, and Colombia.[5]  The Tribunal is currently holding “audiences” (its term for its sessions or hearings) in Mexico, which began in 2011 and will end in 2014.[6]

Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal in Mexico

            The current hearings of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal are taking place throughout communities in Mexico.  Although the international press has given attention to the drug war in Mexico, the scope of human rights violations in Mexico goes far beyond drugs and cartels.  The international press has allowed this larger scope of human rights violations in Mexico to pass largely unnoticed.  The hearings of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal in Mexico allow communities suffering injustices to bring the facts about the injustices and the intensity of their suffering to the world’s attention.

            The next article in this series will examine the structure and the work of the Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal in Mexico.



[1] Russell Tribunal on Palestine, available at http://www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/ (last visited on March 8, 2013).
[2] Janine Odink, The Permanent Peoples’ Tribunal, 11 Neth. Q. Hum. Rts. 229-232 (1993).
[3] Lelio and Lisli Basso Foundation, International Section, Introduction, available at  http://www.internazionaleleliobasso.it/?page_id=207&lang=en (last visited on March 8, 2013).
[4] Lelio and Lisli Basso Foundation, International Section, Introduction, available at  http://www.internazionaleleliobasso.it/?page_id=207&lang=en (last visited on March 8, 2013).
[5] Lelio and Lisli Basso Foundation, International Section, Introduction, available at  http://www.internazionaleleliobasso.it/?page_id=207&lang=en (last visited on March 8, 2013).
[6] Tribunal Permanente de los Pueblos México, available at http://www.tppmexico.org/ (last visited on March 8, 2013).